GRAB(ook) Club: Catching Fire

More than a few spoilers here for Catching Fire

I think we’ve all heard it more than a few times: “If you believe it, you can achieve it!”  Or really, any variation on that general theme.  It’s something I’ve heard from childhood, that nothing is impossible if you really, really want it.  That any dream is achievable with enough hard work and application of resources. 

In Suzanne Collin’s Hunger Games trilogy however, I’m fascinated by how thoroughly this idea is refuted.  Instead of telling children that they can do anything, there is the somewhat fatalistic slogan “may the odds be ever in your favor”.  There’s almost a tacit acceptance that sometimes you are simply the unlucky one and nothing can change that fact.

Katniss has been praised by many as a very active heroine, as opposed to more passive heroines such as Bella Swan from Twilight.  Certainly, Katniss attempts with all her strength to change the course of events throughout the book to keep her loved ones safe.  She actively fights every battle, both literal and more metaphorical.  At the same time, so many events happen which are out of her control.  Katniss is unable to prevent Peeta from going back into the arena in the Quarter Quell.  She can’t, despite her best efforts, prevent uprisings from taking place in the districts.  Knowing nothing about the grand plan to break her out of the arena, Katniss can’t stop Peeta from being captured from the Capitol.

Despite all of Katniss’ ingenuity, hard work, and use of her resources, she is unable to achieve her one goal in Catching Fire:  Peeta’s safety.  She is also unable to achieve a more overarching goal to be left to her own life in peace with her loved ones safe. 

At the same time, Katniss’ efforts are nothing short of heroic.  And I couldn’t help but feel that despite everything and everyone she is unable to save, her actions made a difference. 

Is there a place between “if you believe it, you can achieve it” and “may the odds be ever in your favor”?  Is Katniss able to find it?  Do you think Katniss is in charge of her destiny, or mostly being manipulated by fate or other people?  How do you think this balance plays out in real life?

This post is a part of GRAB(ook) Club organized by Stirrup Queens’ Mel.  When you’re done here, please click over to read the rest of the questions and posts!

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “GRAB(ook) Club: Catching Fire

  1. In some ways, I don’t ever think Katniss really takes charge of her destiny. She might dominate and be decisive and proactive in the arena, but outside of that kind of atmosphere, she has trouble with her personal relationships and can’t forge her destiny there.

    I think real life for most people is a balance between luck and hard work. If you don’t have luck, all the hard work in the world can come to nothing.

  2. I think more often than not, she makes the best (meaning: holds onto free will) of a bad situation. More than many people do in their daily lives. The place where we see that confidence is when she is under duress. The place where it’s missing — and where she seems out-of-sorts and more than a tad wishy-washy — is with her personal relationships. I wish she would have taken a strong stance there too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s